Amazing Reviews

Part of our work on "Steering Law" was submitted to CHI, the most rigorously refereed conference in the field of HCI. A very rare outcome happened to this paper. The six primary referees and one meta reviewer of the paper unanimously gave the paper perfect 5 ratings. We are also very encouraged by the extremely positive comments from these reviewers. Here are some quotes:

• ---

  " I can only wonder why it has taken so long for a paper like this to appear.... "

• ---

  " A beautifully done piece of work."

• ---

  "This paper introduces a very important new theoretical model of great importance to the CHI field."

• ---

  "Yes, yes, yes, yes, and yes. Not trying to be cute here, but the paper is a model for presenting research in a readable, concise, and contextually based manner."

• ---

  "....... this is good stuff."

• ---

  " Clearly, a fine example of an empirical paper, just as submitted."

• ---

  "A very elegant extension of Fitts' law to emerging HCI contexts"

• ---

  "..... *must* be published asap."

• ---

  " This is a model of what such papers should be. A very impressive piece of research. Fundamental, well-founded in theory, yet presented with great clarity and precision."

• ---

  "Nothing is missing, and nothing inessential is included."

• ---

  "They uniformly considered this paper to be excellent on every dimension. I agree, it's a rare paper and there's no question that it should be accepted." - The meta reviewer.